
Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Creami
Crumbl’s Peanut Butter Cup Cookie ft. REESE’S, Creami-style (10/10): a PB2 peanut butter ice cream base with zero mix-ins, topped with a 2-ingredient PB2 + sugar-free maple sauce, a crushed standard Reese’s cup, and sugar-free chocolate syrup. About 380 calories and 43g protein for the whole pint.
You want a 10/10 peanut butter cup ice cream pint where all the texture and flavor contrast lives on top—glossy PB2-maple sauce, real crushed Reese’s cup, and chocolate syrup over a 43g-protein pint.
- Total time
- 24 hr freeze + 5 min rest + spin
- Yield
- 1 serving
- Protein / serving
- ~43g
- Cal / serving
- ~380
- Serving size
- 1 whole finished Creami pint (all toppings included)
Contains: dairy, peanuts, soy
Packaged ingredients change formulas — check the label on what's actually in your kitchen.
Smooth peanut butter ice cream with a rich, maple-sweetened peanut butter swirl, cold milk-chocolate peanut butter cup crunch, and chocolate drizzle.
Ingredients
BASE
MIX-IN
TOPPINGS
Method
- 1BLEND & FREEZE BASE
Blend 1 cup Nurri plain 2% milk, 1/2 serving unflavored whey isolate, 2 tbsp monk-fruit/erythritol sweetener, 1/8 tsp levelled guar gum, a pinch of salt, and 1 tbsp PB2 Original until smooth. Freeze upright on a level surface for 24 hours.
- 2REST & SPIN (NO MIX-INS)
Let the frozen pint sit on the counter for about 5 minutes, then process on Regular Ice Cream. Re-spin if needed for a creamy texture without adding extra liquid.
- 3STIR PB2-MAPLE SAUCE
In a small bowl, stir 1 tbsp PB2 Original with 1 tbsp Maple Grove Farms sugar-free maple syrup until it forms a thick, glossy peanut-maple sauce.
- 4SCOOP & TOP
Scoop the peanut butter ice cream into a bowl and top with the PB2-maple sauce, 1 crushed standard Reese’s peanut butter cup, and 1/2 tbsp Hershey’s sugar-free chocolate syrup.
Three keys to success
- 1No mix-in cycle is used for this build; keep the crushed Reese’s cup, PB2-maple sauce, and chocolate syrup on top so every bite has concentrated texture.
- 2Use a level 1/8 teaspoon of guar gum and do not add extra liquid during the Re-spin.
- 3Nutrition covers the entire finished pint including both tablespoons of PB2 (1 tbsp in the base + 1 tbsp in the sauce), the standard Reese’s cup, and the syrups.
Storage and nutrition
Storage: Freeze the unspun PB2 base upright and level for up to 1 week. Stir the PB2-maple sauce and add the crushed Reese’s cup right when serving.
Reheat: Do not heat the pint.
Lasts: Unspun frozen pint keeps 1 week; enjoy immediately after spinning and topping.



