
Cottage-Cheese Marry Me Chicken
Marry Me chicken, zero heavy cream. One chicken pan, two pasta plates—and 53g protein on the adult plate.
You want a rich, restaurant-style Marry Me chicken pasta dinner with zero heavy cream that hits ~450 calories and 53g protein per adult plate (with 56g dry Carbe Diem penne) while feeding the whole family from one chicken skillet.
- Total time
- 35 min
- Yield
- 8 servings
- Protein
- ~53g
- Calories
- ~450
Ingredients
Shared
Adult Plate — 1/8 Chicken & Sauce + 56g Dry Carbe Diem Penne (~450 cal / 53g protein)
Kid Plate — Mild Shared Chicken & Sauce + Regular Barilla Pasta
Method
Shared base
Cook once — this part works for everyone.
- 1
Blend cottage cheese, milk, grated three-cheese blend, and garlic seasoning until completely smooth.
- 2
Pat chicken thighs dry, season, and sear in batches in 1 tbsp tomato-jar oil until browned and at least 165°F internally. Rest and chop into bite-size pieces.
- 3
Lower heat, briefly cook drained sun-dried tomatoes and minced garlic, deglaze with 1/2 cup bone broth, and wilt 5 oz spinach.
- 4
Take pan off heat briefly, temper a little warm pan liquid into the blended sauce, return the chopped chicken, and fold in the sauce over lowest heat without boiling.
Adult Plate — 1/8 Chicken & Sauce + 56g Dry Carbe Diem Penne (~450 cal / 53g protein)
- 5
Cook 56g dry Carbe Diem penne per adult plate according to package directions.
- 6
Top with 1/8 of the shared Marry Me chicken and cottage-cheese cream sauce batch and finish with red chili flakes (~450 cal, 53g protein, 44g total carbs, 25g fiber, 15g fat).
Kid Plate — Mild Shared Chicken & Sauce + Regular Barilla Pasta
- 5
Cook regular Barilla pasta separately and serve with a kid-sized portion of the mild shared Marry Me chicken and sauce (skip the chili flakes; no public child macro target is claimed).
Adult plate | Kid plate
Adult Plate — 1/8 Chicken & Sauce + 56g Dry Carbe Diem Penne (~450 cal / 53g protein)
Macros not published for this plate — portion it to their appetite.
What makes it different
- 56g dry Carbe Diem penne per adult plate
- Red chili flakes to taste (about 1/2 tsp)
Kid Plate — Mild Shared Chicken & Sauce + Regular Barilla Pasta
Macros not published for this plate — portion it to their appetite.
What makes it different
- 42g dry regular Barilla pasta per kid plate (or portion to suit appetite)
Three keys to success
- 1Blend the 440g Good Culture 2% cottage cheese, 1/4 cup Nurri whole protein milk, 60g grated Parmesan/Romano/Asiago blend, and garlic seasoning until completely smooth before heating the sauce.
- 2Cook the adult Carbe Diem pasta and kid regular Barilla pasta in separate pots according to package directions, and reserve a little starchy pasta water.
- 3Sear the seasoned chicken thighs in batches in 1 tbsp sun-dried-tomato jar oil until browned and at least 165°F internally; rest and cut into bite-size pieces.
Go deeper
Storage and nutrition
Storage: Store the cooked chicken-and-sauce batch and the cooked pastas in separate airtight containers in the refrigerator for up to 3–4 days.
Reheat: Warm gently on low heat or at 50% microwave power with a splash of reserved pasta water or milk so the cottage-cheese sauce stays smooth.
Lasts: Up to 3–4 days refrigerated (enough for 2 family dinners for 3 adults and 2 kids).
Watch the full cook
Pairs With Your Leftovers
Cook this next
Recipes that share the most ingredients with this one — same brands or proteins in your fridge are reusable here.

Creamy Sausage Spinach Pasta
Shared:
Spinach • Fresh Chilies • Penne Pasta • Chicken Bone Broth

Chili Mac and Cheese
Shared:
Chicken Breast • Penne Pasta • Cottage Cheese • Chicken Bone Broth

High-Protein Weeknight Butter Chicken
Shared:
Chicken Thighs • Chicken Breast • Cottage Cheese • Chicken Bone Broth

